Have you ever asked someone for a quick update…
…and gotten a 20-slide PowerPoint deck?
It’s impressive.
But it’s also probably more than you needed. And it may have taken longer than it should have.
So here’s the real question:
Did that extra preparation help—or did it slow things down?
What Gets Rewarded Gets Done
As leaders, we need to remember a simple truth:
What gets rewarded gets done.
If we consistently praise thoroughness, polish, and highly prepared presentations, we will get more of them.
But that leads to a deeper question:
How much preparation do we actually need?
This is both a personal question and an organizational one. Because whether we realize it or not, we are constantly signaling what matters most.
Progress vs. Polish: What Are You Reinforcing?
In many organizations, there’s an unspoken tension between progress and polish.
- Do we recognize people for moving things forward?
- Or do we reward them for making things look perfect?
The same question shows up in meetings:
- Are we valuing insight—clear thinking and useful contribution?
- Or are we rewarding volume—which often comes from overpreparation?
When we reward polish over progress, we often slow everything down.
Overpreparation Is Often Fear in Disguise
Let’s call this what it often is.
Overpreparation is frequently fear in disguise.
- Fear of being wrong
- Fear of being judged
- Fear of not having the answers
So we prepare more. And more. And more.
But as leaders, we need to create an environment where “rough draft thinking” is acceptable. Where people can share ideas before they are fully formed.
Because progress doesn’t require perfection.
Does More Preparation Lead to Better Decisions?
It might feel like it should—but in today’s world, that’s not always true.
We are operating in an environment of constant change and uncertainty. And that means:
More preparation doesn’t necessarily lead to better decisions.
In fact, it can lead to:
- Delays
- Missed opportunities
- Analysis paralysis
Trying to prepare our way past uncertainty is often a losing strategy.
Instead, we need to be clear about what “good enough” looks like—and move forward from there.
Leaders Set the Pace (Whether They Mean To or Not)
Here’s the part that matters most:
Leaders set the pace and the expectations.
- If you expect progress, you will get momentum.
- If you expect perfection, you will get hesitation.
Your team is always watching what you praise, what you question, and what you allow.
If you consistently reward overpreparation—even unintentionally—you will get more of it.
The Power of Iteration Over Perfection
In most cases, the best path forward isn’t a perfect answer—it’s a better answer over time.
That comes through iteration.
Taking a step.
Learning.
Adjusting.
Moving again.
When we shift from perfection to progress, we don’t lower standards—we increase speed, learning, and ultimately, results.
A Simple Leadership Shift
If you want to reduce overpreparation and increase effectiveness, start here:
- Ask for clarity, not completeness
- Reward insight, not volume
- Normalize draft thinking
- Define what “good enough” looks like
- Model progress over perfection
These small shifts can create a big change in how your team works—and how quickly they deliver results.
0 comments